Now and Then & Over Again

Now and Then & Over Again is a family owned and operated store with antiques, collectibles and unique items for sale from nearly 150 vendors in 8000 square feet of space in the heart of central Ohio. We offer not only great prices and selection but the best in friendly Midwest service.

While you are visiting our store in beautiful Utica, Ohio "The Gateway to Amish Country", we can point you to some local attractions like our local favorite Watts resturaunt or the famous home of Velvet Ice Cream, Ye Olde Mill. If you have the time, head over toward the Newark Heath area and see some sites like seven-story, 180,000-square-foot basket building designed by The Longaberger Company or head to the quaint town of Granville, home of Denison University, to see the Buxton Inn, Cherry Valley Lodge Granville Inn and relax down own with some Whit's Frozen Custard.

Serving others is our passion and calling. Check out our reviews and come see for yourself why people from not only Licking and Knox County but all over Ohio, Pennsylavania, Indiana, West Virginia and even Michigan keep coming back to experience the selection and service we provide.